Wonder Woman
Broers
La región salvaje
En amont du fleuve
Daughters of the Dust
You, the critic

An Oversimplification of Her Beauty

United States, 2012 | Terence Nance
For Slow Criticism 2012, Eugenio Renzi checked in from Rome to examine the American debut feature An Oversimplification of Her Beauty. "Writing this short note about the film has been one of the hardest (also most interesting) things that occurred in this critic's life. The reader will understand why at the very end."

You are a film critic. She is a filmmaker. You have known each other since you've worked as an actor on one of her films, during the summer of 2011. Supposedly, you are mutually in love. You propose to her to spend a holiday in Rome. She accepts. You arrive before her, and stay a few days with your Italian family. She will come later.

So you are waiting. The days are long. You try to distract your mind by working a little. The Rotterdam film festival send you a link to a stream of a movie selected for the 2012 edition: An Oversimplification of Her Beauty directed by Terence Nance. You have to write a review of it. It is an idea of Dana. Dana has a lot of ideas. You like both, Dana and her ideas. So you will try to do the job. Are you supposed to write it in English, that you barely speak? You don't now. You forget to ask.

At the beginning, you don't like very much Nance's film. You should say that you don't like, in general, this kind of film. What kind? New York kind: intimist, analytical, arty kind of film. All your experience as a French critic says to you: do not trust this. Especially if it is good, if the voice-over is well written (it is), if the image is powerful (it is), if the graphic is intelligent (yes, it is): you should stay away. Hawks would never do such a thing.

But. First, you are no more in the Cahiers du Cinéma. Second, you are getting old. You don't really believe in critical dogmas any more as much as you (fanatically) used to.

So, in fact, you like the film. The style, the characters, the story. You appreciate the way the same short story line stands up for 88 minutes in front of you like a simple and devastating anatomy of a relationship.

You could say that the story of the film is like a Hitchcock dream: a guy loves a girl. But this is not a Hollywood movie. This is a NYer kind movie. In NY cinema, feelings are straight actions. Actions that you can show in a theater. So, here is the action: the guy comes back home. He has a rendezvous with the girl he is in love with. He just settles down, he discovers that he has a missed call on his phone from her. Of course, he calls her back. She says that she has just arrived home and she will not able to come to his place as planned. At this point, a voice-over asks directly to you audience: if you were this guy, how would you feel?

You think that it's a pretty good question. But also the kind of question the cinema you love does not ask. You remember an affair of Cary Grant that ends at the top of the Empire State Building. Leo MacCarey has taken you on a long trip across the ocean before bringing you up to this building, so you can finally feel like Cary Grant feels, waiting for his "her", who would not come to the appointment. But MacCarey does not ask you to feel this way. Nor tries to explain you how you should feel. But he knows you do. That's why he is a genius.

An Oversimplification of Her Beauty does ask. Which is much more a literary then a cinematographic way of expressing things. Which is why you do not feel entirely comfortable with it. You will see the main scene, the telephone scene, many times during the movie. Each time, the director brings you there, to the question "how would you feel", from a different perspective. It reminds you of a Queneau book (based on a Kojève interpretation of Hegel's Logic): Exercises in Style, a collection of 99 retellings of the same story, each in a different style. The point of Queneau is to transcend ordinary existence, and get some kind of totality, by an oversimplification of the existence itself (one atomic fact). Here we are talking about love. The big issue. You could not say if the film succeeds in surrounding this archetypal romance experience and look it over from all the possible points of view. For sure, you are impressed by a scene. It's an animation. The hero is in front of the girl he loves. Suddenly, as Alice in Wonderland, he starts to get smaller. Soon the girl looks like a giant. Then another girl comes and starts to grow until she becomes as big as the first girl. You find this representation of how people feel each other very realistic. A is in love with B. So in A's eyes B occupies a big space. Then A stops loving B and falls for C. B becomes very small. She doesn't quite exist any more. C takes all the place. It's exactly like that. And you know it. But you have never seen it on a screen before.

So, there are indeed some powerful scenes in the film. But you still feel that there is something artificial, intellectual at the core of it. You do not really know how you would feel if you were the guy, coming home, finding the missed call of the girl that has an appointment with him, calling her back, and discovering that finally she won't come.

Then you stop thinking. You are in Rome. You are waiting for your girlfriend. She has a flight from Paris in the evening. You look at your phone. There is a missed call from her. Of course, you call her back. She said that she just arrived home. She will not come to Rome.

Eugenio Renzi



top
An Oversimplification of Her Beauty

Februari 2012 #340

Slow Criticism 2012

Titelindex


ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ1&


O

O AMOR NATURAL
O apóstolo
O BROTHER, WHERE ART THOU?
O FANTASMA
O PRIMEIRO DIA
O SANGUE
O'HORTEN
THE O.J. SIMPSON STORY
O.K. GARAGE
The OA
OASIS
Oasis: Supersonic
OBER
THE OBJECT OF MY AFFECTION
Oblivion
Ocaso
OCCIDENT
OCEAN WORLD 3D
OCEAN'S 13
OCEAN'S ELEVEN
OCEAN'S TWELVE
OCEANS
OCTOBER SKY
Oculus
THE ODD COUPLE II
ODESSA... ODESSA!
L' ODEUR DE LA PAPAYE VERTE
L' odyssée
OEROEG
OESTERS VAN NAM KEE
OF FREAKS AND MEN
Of Horses and Men
Of ik gek ben
OFF SCREEN
Office Christmas Party
OFFICE KILLER
OFFICE SPACE
Offline
OFFSIDE
Les ogres
Oh Boy
OH HAPPY DAY
OI! WARNING
Okja (Bong Joon-ho over)
Old Cats
OLD DOGS
THE OLD MAN WHO READ LOVE STORIES
OLD SCHOOL
Oldboy
OLDBOY (2003)
Oldboy (2013)
DE OLIFANT EN DE SLAK
OLIVER TWIST
OLIVETTI 82
OLIVIER ETC.
OLIVIER OLIVIER
El olivo
EL OLVIDO
Olympus Has Fallen
Om de wereld in 50 concerten
OMAGH
Omar
Omar m'a tuer
L' OMBRE DU DOUTE
THE OMEN 666
HET OMGEKEERDE PERSPECTIEF (INVERTED PERSPECTIVE)
DE OMWEG
ON A CLEAR DAY
ON CONNAÎT LA CHANSON
ON DEADLY GROUND
ON THE BEAT
ON THE LINE
ON THE MOVE — MIGRATIE IN EUROPA
On the Other Side
On the Road
ONCE
ONCE IN A LIFETIME
Once Upon a Forest
ONCE UPON A TIME IN AMERICA
Once Upon A Time in Anatolia
ONCE UPON A TIME IN CHINA
ONCE UPON A TIME IN MEXICO
ONCE UPON A TIME...WHEN WE WERE COLOURED
ONCE WERE WARRIORS
Onder de oppervlakte
Onder het hart
Onder ons
HET ONDERGRONDS ORKEST (THE UNDERGROUND ORCHESTRA)
ONDINE
THE ONE
One Day
One Day When the Rain Falls (Rumah dan musin hujan)
One Direction: This Is Us
ONE FINE DAY
One Floor Below (Previously Unreleased)
One for the Money
ONE HOUR PHOTO
The One I Love
One Life
ONE MISSED CALL
ONE NIGHT STAND
ONE PERFECT DAY
ONE WAY TICKET TO OBLIVION
ONG-BAK: MUAY THAI WARRIOR
Only God Forgives
Only Lovers Left Alive
The Only Son
ONLY THE STRONG
ONLY YOU
ONTDAAN
De ontmaagding van Eva van End
De ontsnapping
ONZE EEUW
Onze jongens
DE OOGST VAN DE STILTE
OOGVERBLINDEND
Oorlogsgeheimen
OORLOGSRUST
OORLOGSWINTER
OP AFBETALING
OP EIGEN HOUTJE
OPAL DREAM
OPEN HEARTS
OPEN RANGE
Open Up to Me
OPEN WATER
OPERA JAWA
Operatie Noordpool
OPERATION DUMBO DROP
THE OPPOSITE OF SEX
ORA O MAI PIÙ
ORANGE COUNTY
ORBIS PICTUS
DE ORDENING
ORDINARY DECENT CRIMINAL
ORDINARY MAN
EL ORFANATO
ORGAZMO
Orla de kikkerslikker 3D
ORLANDO
ORPHAN
Orpheline (Arnaud des Pallières en Christelle Berthevas over)
OS MUTANTES
OSAMA
OSCAR AND LUCINDA
OSCAR ET LA DAME ROSE
Oscuro animal
Oslo, 31 August
OSMOSIS JONES
OSS 117: RIO NE REPOND PLUS
OSSOS
THE OSTERMAN WEEKEND
OSWALD
OTHELLO
THE OTHER FINAL
THE OTHER GUYS
THE OTHER MAN
The Other Side (Roberto Minervini over)
The Other Side of Hope
The Other Side of Sleep
THE OTHER SISTER
The Other Woman
THE OTHERS
Otto is een neushoorn
OUDE TONGEN
Ouija
Ouija: Origin Of Evil
Our Beloved Month of August
OUR DAILY BREAD
Our Grand Despair
Our Idiot Brother
Our Kind of Traitor
Our Little Sister (Hirokazu Kore-eda over)
Our Nixon
Out 1
OUT COLD
Out of Love
Out of Nature
OUT OF SIGHT
Out of the Furnace
OUT OF TIME
THE OUT-OF-TOWNERS
OUTBREAK
OUTSIDE PROVIDENCE
Ouwehoeren
Over Canto
OVER HER DEAD BODY
OVER HET MET GEWEREN IN DE LUCHT VUREN
OVER MIJN LIPPEN
OVER THE HEDGE
De overgave
Overlord
An Oversimplification of Her Beauty
OYUN
Oz the Great and Powerful
OZU ANNIVERSARY COLLECTION